Bankruptcy Processes and Debt Restructuring (CFA Level 1): Bankruptcy Frameworks around the World, Reorganization vs. Liquidation, and Reorganization. Key definitions, formulas, and exam tips.
I’ll never forget the first time I ran into a Chapter 11 filing at a company I was analyzing. I sort of gulped, looked at the giant stack of court documents on my desk, and thought, “Wow, this is more complicated than I realized.” And, honestly, it was. Corporate bankruptcy and debt restructuring can be overwhelming—even for seasoned finance folks—because the process touches on corporate governance, legal frameworks, complex negotiations, and a swirl of creditor interests. But once you break down the steps, it’s not so bad. Really.
The purpose of this section is to walk you through the key concepts and typical processes involved in corporate bankruptcy and debt restructuring. We’ll start by contrasting two main approaches—reorganization and liquidation—then delve into how creditors assert their claims, how automatic stays and DIP financing work, and why some firms go the “informal” route rather than a full-blown court-supervised proceeding. By the end, you’ll get a sense of how each stakeholder might navigate these murky waters and what it all means for bondholders, equity holders, and everyone in between.
While bankruptcy laws differ across jurisdictions, most systems revolve around two central paths:
If you’re in the United States, you’ve probably heard of Chapter 11 (reorganization) and Chapter 7 (liquidation). In the UK, there’s administration (roughly analogous to Chapter 11). Meanwhile, in Canada, you might see the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA). Regardless of the labels, the overarching rationale is largely the same: to give financially distressed companies a formal path to resolving their debt load, whether that’s restructuring or winding down for good.
Reorganization entails creating a plan—often called a Reorganization Plan—to modify the company’s capital structure in a way that allows operations to continue. It might extend debt maturities, reduce coupon rates, or even convert part of the debt into equity (we often call that a debt-for-equity swap). In many jurisdictions, the court places an Automatic Stay on debt collection efforts. This is basically a “pause button” preventing creditors from seizing assets or demanding immediate repayment. The idea is to give the firm breathing space to figure out a plan that maximizes overall value.
If creditors and the company’s management can’t voluntarily agree (that’s the dream scenario), there can be something known as a “cramdown.” Courts might force certain dissenting creditors to accept a plan if it’s reasonable and meets specific legal criteria. Think of it as the court saying: “Look, we have to keep this business going, and this plan is fair enough—so you can’t block it.”
When all is said and done and the reorganization is approved, some companies may adopt “Fresh Start Accounting.” Under these rules, the reorganized company effectively resets its balance sheet at fair values, giving it, well, a fresh start.
Not all bankrupt companies survive. Sometimes the best option is to liquidate—that is, sell off the assets piece by piece to repay creditors. In U.S. parlance, that’s Chapter 7 bankruptcy. For bondholders and other unsecured creditors, liquidation often yields less than face value, which is a sobering reminder that bond investing always carries default risk.
Investors often measure the company’s Liquidation Value—an estimate of what its assets would fetch in a quick sale. Liquidation Value usually runs below the going-concern value because you’re forced to sell quickly, often at distressed prices. If you suspect liquidation is likely, you can’t simply assume you’ll be made whole on your bonds, no matter the original credit rating.
Bankruptcy is a fight over a shrinking pie, so who gets paid and in what order really matters. The capital structure normally has a “waterfall” priority:
Under normal circumstances, equity is last in line. In many reorganizations, equity holders might get wiped out or see serious dilution. Meanwhile, secured creditors usually have the safest claim, because they can rely on their collateral. That said, even secured creditors face haircuts in certain scenarios. A “Haircut” is just a nice way of saying you’re forced to take less than you were promised—like being owed $100 but only receiving $70.
The Automatic Stay is a critical feature in many formal bankruptcies. Essentially, once a bankruptcy proceeding begins, creditors can’t enforce or collect on their debts without court permission. Ever had someone repeatedly knocking on your door for payment? Now imagine the court says, “Stop knocking temporarily. Let’s figure this out.” The stay gives the company precious time to develop a strategy. Without it, you could have a free-for-all, with creditors racing to grab assets as quickly as possible.
Now, if a company is truly strapped for cash, how can it keep the lights on while it’s in bankruptcy? This is where DIP Financing comes in. A lender might offer new credit to the bankrupt company, typically at very favorable priority status—super-priority, we call it—so that no one else can outrank the DIP lender’s claim. Why would a lender do this? Usually, it’s loaded with conditions, but if successful, it can be quite profitable because DIP lenders often earn higher rates and robust collateral protections. It’s a lifeline that can help distressed firms buy time during reorganization.
Formal restructuring is where you have a full-blown legal process under some bankruptcy code. Many times, this includes:
An out-of-court restructuring is a more flexible, less public approach. Companies sometimes opt for a “workout” arrangement with key creditors to achieve extended maturities, lower interest rates, or partial debt forgiveness. This route avoids the stigma and complexity of going to court, but it demands that all the major players cooperate. If many creditors hold out or refuse to compromise, an informal restructuring might fail, forcing a formal filing.
A popular variant is the Pre-Packaged Bankruptcy (“Pre-Pack”), where most of the big creditors have already agreed on the restructuring plan prior to the official filing. The moment the company files, the plan is ready for a quick approval, saving both time and legal expenses.
When we talk about “debt restructuring,” you’ll see a handful of go-to tools companies and creditors use:
Anyone who’s ever tried to plan a family reunion knows that bigger groups often mean bigger complications. Creditor negotiation is no different—some folks will be quick to compromise, while others dig in. That’s why creditors often form committees. A committee’s mandate is to represent various creditor classes in negotiations. An unsecured creditors’ committee is especially common in U.S. Chapter 11 proceedings, for example. Their job is to protect the interests of that creditor group, ensuring no unscrupulous deals slide through.
Legitimate financial disclosures are crucial here. After all, how can creditors decide whether to accept 50 cents on the dollar if they’re not sure whether the company’s balance sheet is accurate or if certain assets are undervalued? That’s why professional valuations, balanced governance, and transparent reporting can make or break a restructuring.
Let’s take a hypothetical scenario: WhaleCo is a mid-sized manufacturing firm that borrowed heavily to expand its factory network. Unfortunately, a demand slump hit, and WhaleCo found itself unable to meet debt obligations. After consulting with a turnaround specialist, WhaleCo determines that an informal deal with its major bondholders might work. Here’s the approach:
In this case, WhaleCo avoids bankruptcy, investors see partial recovery (plus potential upside from the new stock positions), and a crisis is averted.
Below is a simplified diagram (using Mermaid) of how a typical bankruptcy might unfold—especially relevant for reorganizations:
flowchart TB
A["Company <br/>Files for Bankruptcy"] --> B["Automatic Stay <br/>Goes into Effect"]
B --> C["Debtor-in-Possession <br/>Financing?"]
C --> D{"Develop <br/>Reorganization Plan"}
D --> E["Creditor Voting <br/>on Plan"]
E --> F{"Plan Confirmation<br/>(Possibly Cramdown)"}
F --> G["Implementation <br/>of Plan"]
G --> H["Emergence <br/>From Bankruptcy"]
Bankruptcy can look pretty scary on the surface, but it’s essentially a structured way to figure out who gets paid what (and when) in a worst-case scenario. For bondholders and other creditors, it highlights the importance of understanding the priority of claims and the real risk of default. For companies, it underscores the importance of prudent capital management, transparent governance, and constructive engagement with stakeholders during times of financial distress. In some cases, the business emerges more resilient than before—albeit with some new owners and a trimmed-down balance sheet.
Important Notice: FinancialAnalystGuide.com provides supplemental CFA study materials, including mock exams, sample exam questions, and other practice resources to aid your exam preparation. These resources are not affiliated with or endorsed by the CFA Institute. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned exclusively by CFA Institute. Our content is independent, and we do not guarantee exam success. CFA Institute does not endorse, promote, or warrant the accuracy or quality of our products.